Tuesday, October 21, 2008

Not without our allies.

Jenn and I are blessed to be surrounded by parents, siblings, grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, colleagues, and friends who treat us like normal people.

Please take a moment to think about the tail end of that statement.

Put another way, there are hundreds of people in our lives who do not view us as sinful, corrupted, or abnormal simply because we're gay.

This buffer of affirmation and unconditional love protects us to a degree that, sometimes, when we're in safe, non-public places, we forget that we bear the crude, unfabulously flaming pink brandings of the letter 'H' across our chests. 'H' standing for homosexual, the bristling clinical moniker for gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgender persons used as the standard catch-all in churches, the media and many other institutions within our culture.

Sadly, these moments of normalcy are limited and isolated for us, or any 'homo', in our society.

In 2006, the majority of Wisconsin voters voted to ban same-sex marriage in our state Constitution. Marriage, the amendment said, shall be defined as a union between one man and one woman. Furthermore, the amendment said, any relationships similar to or resembling marriage, like civil unions and domestic partnerships, are also banned.

The truth here is plain: this was a crushing discriminatory act against at least -- at least -- ten percent of the state population. For the first time, the famously progressive state of Wisconsin carved hate into the document designed to protect all of its residents.

Every day, gay persons make decisions with regard to revealing their sexual orientation that straight people never have to make. I consider carefully how necessary and how safe it is for me to reveal that I'm gay in situations that many non-LGBT persons might not imagine in their wildest dreams. In most states, and at the federal level, we are not protected in the workplace, in our relationships, as co-parents of our children, or against hate crimes. In 1994, only two states prohibited harassment and discrimination based on sexual orientation in public schools. In 2004, that number grew to eight states -- out of fifty! Right now, it is still legal in 42 states to harass or discriminate against students, teachers, and other school personnel in public school environments.

We live in such a heterosexually-dominant culture that it's easy not to notice that ten percent, or by some estimates more than ten percent, of the general population does not have the same civil rights as the majority population. The US Constitution promises equality for all, yet state by state, LGBT individuals, couples, and families are being kicked while they're down. And while we have experienced some victories, like achieving full marriage equality in Massachusetts, Connecticut, and California, those victories are tentative at best.

On November 4th, Arizona and Florida will present voters with amendments to ban gay marriage, similar to the ones that have already passed in Wisconsin, Virginia, Michigan, South Dakota, South Carolina, Idaho, Texas, Kansas, Utah, Oklahoma, Ohio, North Dakota, Louisiana, Kentucky, Georgia, Arkansas, Alabama, Nebraska, Tennessee, Colorado, Oregon, Montana, Missouri, Mississippi, Nevada, Alaska, and Hawaii.

In California, where equality resounded from San Francisco to San Diego and where hundreds of gay and lesbian couples have been legally married since June 2008, millions of dollars are being spent by the religious right to persuade voters to rape and plunder these couples of their long overdue joy and civil rights.

Personally, I don't get it. I don't understand why any opponent of same-sex marriage would feel threatened by what Jenn and I share. I don't understand why, when I know from personal experience that there are hundreds of people in our lives alone who support full marriage equality, these amendments keep passing. Is it that our family and friends are telling us one thing and voting contrarily? Is it that these hundreds of people we know and the hundreds of thousands more like them are not voting at all?

Jenn has a theory. She says that, for us, it makes sense to focus so much on this issue because it impacts our lives directly on a visceral level. She says that, while straight allies mean well, it's not at the forefront of their everyday realities. The urgency isn't there for them like it is for us. There may be some truth to this theory. I remember one of our friends telling me right before the Wisconsin ban passed in 2006 to, in so many words, stop harping about our lack of rights.

What this friend doesn't understand is that the battle for full civil rights, full equality, and full inclusion, as promised by our forebears, will not be won without her.

Last week, Jenn and I received an email from her mom, who lives in Florida. The opening paragraph of her email leaped from the screen with its exclamation points. "I wrote to the editor!", she said. "And it got published!" We read on, tears curling from their hiding spots, floating on the love and joy propagated only by the healthy indignation and compassion demonstrated in her letter.

I've included her letter below. Before you read it, please think carefully about this. Politicians tell us that LGBT persons will receive equal rights in due time. The thing is, though, that our time is happening now. We are excluded now. We are struggling now. We need to win this battle against hate and discrimination now.

I understand how it may seem like this issue is not at the forefront of your everyday reality. But it is. As long as anyone lacks civil rights, everyone else's civil rights hang in the balance.

We can achieve equality in this country, once and for all -- but not without our allies.

Dear Editor,

I'd like to comment on a quote [from a teacher] in the article in Sunday, Oct. 12th's front-page article on gay marriage. The quote said that children from same-sex homes are very ashamed to let people know they have parents of the same sex. That feeling in our children is a product of our outdated, narrow-minded society of today. Shame on us for letting our children have this belief. We should be teaching them that a family is any group of people living under the same roof who love and support each other. That can be a mom, dad and children, two moms and children, two dads and children, or a single parent or grandparent and children. All of these families are prevalent in today's society and we as teachers and parents have the responsibility to help our young ones feel comfortable and happy with the family they have.

When I lived up north, this same amendment came up on our ballot. The Sunday before voting day, the minister of the church I attended openly told his congregation they should vote yes on this amendment. I wonder how many people besides me felt very uncomfortable with the idea that anyone following his advice has the right to tell someone else how they should live their life. All Americans should have the same civil rights no matter what their race, religion, gender, or sexuality is. I thought that was established a long time ago.

Some day when my daughter and her life partner adopt children, I know these lucky children will feel loved, secure and proud of the family they have. Hopefully by then, this country will be ready to accept all Americans and our children won't feel ashamed anymore.

Sincerely,
Jenn's mom



18 comments:

Betsey Booms said...

With tears in my eyes, I have to tell you that I absolutely hate that you HAVE to feel this way.

If I couldn't proudly tell all about my family, my heart would be broken in two.

Knowing that my friends have a broken heart every day of their lives saddens me to no end.

I don't get it. I just honestly don't get it.

I think most parents think about the what if's of their children. What if my son/daughter is gay? This issue affects all of us whether we know it or not.

I suppose it's strange that I don't expect to know until my children know for themselves. I don't assume that my children will be 'straight'. I do assume that they will be happy and find people who will love them for them and they they will be treated fairly in the world.

We can see where assuming will get me.

Jenn is a very lucky woman to have such a wonderful mother.

Natalie said...

Your story brings tears to my eyes, there are so many "heterosexual" people who DO care. I hope you don't mind, but I linked to you a couple of days ago, using you as an example of how REAL gay, lesbian, homosexual (not sure of the proper term?) relationships are.

It just infuriates me that people think it's OK to put amendments on constitutions DENYING someone rights. HOW are these things ever even allowed on the ballot? Our country has its head stuck up it's rear in so many ways, and this is a prime example of how.

I live in Arizona and as I was driving to work today (five miles straight up the same road) I saw no less than thirty YES FOR MARRIAGE, VOTE YES on PROP 102 signs and I wanted to pull over, get out of my car and stomp each one of them into the ground. And then I wanted to take red paint and write JUDGEMENTAL HYPOCRITES on them (and some expletives), but I knew that would be stooping to their level. There was one section of road, about 300 feet long, that had these signs at regular intervals.

I'm not going to pretend that I understand your lifestyle, because I don't, no more than you understand mine. But I am not of the belief of that which I don't understand is dangerous. I hope you understand what I am trying to say.

Look, I'm working on my second divorce, but SOMEHOW I still have the choice to make a bad decision a third time and it infuriates me that other people have no right to marry the love of their life.

Natalie said...

P.S. You know at least one Arizonan that will be voting against this state's Prop 102.

Maggie, Dammit said...

I love you.

furiousBall said...

Listen, I'm a jaded divorced guy, so I don't know why anyone wants to get married.

But seriously, how backwards are these morons that they think that holding on to this last moral kick ball and going home with it is going to win for them? Here's the way I look at it, we as a collective group need to be happy and love is enough of a greased ball in an unlit room for any of us to grasp. Love is a union and whatever rights our society has set aside for this union is deserved by all not just the rich bible humpers.

Did I say humper?

the cubicle's backporch said...

Reading this makes me proud that my company offers domestic partner benefits.

I don't understand why people should have a say in what makes other people happy. Is allowing gay couples to get married going to make my life worse? No.

I don't understand it. Maybe we should ban women from marrying jerks. Now THAT would get something accomplished. heh.

Xbox4NappyRash said...

We live in a silly, silly world.

I'm happy you have those allies. I'm happier they have you.

Mr Lady said...

Oh, lord woman. I am just so so so sorry that you even have to WRITE this. It's so wrong, so veryvery wrong. Jenn's mom rocks. The world should be FULL of Jenn's moms, I think.

Scott said...

Amen, Amen, Amen. As a partnered gay man, having to wonder how I'm going to take time off from school when my partner's mother dies leaves me feeling a bit disgusted with society and the government. A straight colleague in my district gets three days to attend a funeral and celebrate an in-law's life. Me? Either take my two personal days (I have to pay for my sub) and a full-deduct day, or lie and say I'm sick. This is the kind of stuff most people don't understand. It's about justice and civil rights - it's NOT about "condoning a lifestyle". When, O Lord, will they EVER understand?

becky w. said...

Erika,

I found your blog a few days ago, and I am surprised and humbled that you visited mine. I hope our no side wins again in AZ... we did it 2 years ago. As Scott's comment says and I think so many hetero couples just don't realize, there is so much more at stake than the "right to marry." People like you who want to marry the love of your life, who happens to be the "wrong" gender (not my personal opinion) don't have access to ANY of the benefits afforded to us by our legally married status. It is so beyond discrimination, it isn't fathomable. Anyway, I hope to be considered an "ally" and will keep coming back to your blog because I would like to better know how to champion your cause.

P.S. Another no vote you can count on in AZ.

Kari D. said...

As a lesbian living in CA who just got legally married on my 20th anniversary, I can't tell you how sad and infuriated and frustrated it makes me to see signs in support of Prop 8 around my town. As you said, I just don't get it! Why would anyone want to put discrimination of any kind put into the constitution?? Crazy! Also, my wife and I have 8 kids and not one of them is ashamed about having two moms. In fact, it is quite the opposite. They just assume that every family is different and feel loved and adored by us and all who surround us. Thanks goodness for that! I hope no child has to feel ashamed! When you two decide to start your family, I'm sure they will feel loved, adored and cherished like every child who has one, two, four or ten loving parents should! By the way, your mom rocks! :)

Captain Steve said...

Jenn has an awesome mom and you have a great mother-in-law.

Mollyfa said...

I can't agree with you more. I just don't get how allowing more people to enter into marriage hurts marriage. And as far as proponents of civil unions, that's all well and good, I suppose, but the fact of the matter is, separate is not equal.

My brother is gay, and I am constantly floored by the different experiences that we had growing up. I knew that no matter what I did, my family would always be there for me. He grew up believing that he would be disowned as soon as he came out. Thankfully, he was wrong. He too has found a similar buffer. When will this country learn that we are damaging our children with messages of hate?

Thank you for writing about this so eloquently.

Tera Rose said...

ok you may not catch this comment because it is on a past post...

first...come on over here to Connecticut- besides making marriage legal we've had hate crime protection for some time now (maybe not long enough)....

second- on your partner's thought that it isn't a major issue to most people- I'd have to differ.

I think the problem is that most people are not gay or strait- not a politically correct opinion, but mine- and that the people who scream the loudest againt homosexuals have the inability to have peace with their own gayness- or gay thoughts.

I further add that there are some people so ignorant, insecure and angry and have the need to control others....well, those my friends are the ones that become the hatefilled pastors and led groups on their crusades...

Oh, I could talk about this for hours....

but this is your blog...

I am glad to read that you have loving family and support...if we all had that, my guess is there would be less of those hate filled people...

:)

Tera Rose said...

ok, I was confused- it's NOT a past post...lol...

I came here through someone else's blog and read the post with the protesting video McCain visit..

sorry...it's a blonde thang.

Anonymous said...

Thanks,Erika! As usual, what you wrote was beautiful and well written. I so appreciate you adding my letter to your blog so that more people can read it. Thanks to all the commenters for your nice remarks. Erika and Jenn are a wonderful couple and my husband and I couldn't be happier that they have found each other. As you can see by the picture Erika included, Jenn's joy when she saw Erika come down the aisle was overwhelming that beautiful day.

Since I sent Jenn and Erika the Letter to the Editor directly by e-mail, the title the paper gave my letter was not included. The editor called it "Accepting People." I think that says it all. By the way, this newspaper recommends that they vote "No" on this amendment (which is the way we are supposed to vote.) Lets hope all of Florida does the same!

Jenn's Mom

mntnlover77 said...

Hi Erika,

I live in Colorado, and I was ashamed when Colorado banned gay marriage. Colorado is progressive in many ways, but so backwards in others. I have so many gay and lesbian friends- I can't imagine ever telling them to shut up about their rights. Though it doesn't affect my life in the same way as it does you or my friends, it does affect my life. I want those I love to be happy, and when they're denied a fundamental right, all of society suffers. Know that this absolutely breaks not only my heart (Some straight girl in Boulder, CO) but the hearts of many other heterosexuals. You are not alone in this fight.

loveyh said...

Your mom is amazing. I can see how she raised such a wonderful woman. I am fighting with you and for you.

And my children are being raised to love all people, not just ones who think like they do. Maybe someone forgot to inform the other side that God loves all the people in the world--not just the straight ones.